A new approach on defence – updated

PolicyA new approach on defence – updated

A new approach on defence – updated

In a Downing Street address a day before his US departure, Keir Starmer announced the UK will increase its defence spending to build Britain’s industrial base. The government is still sticking to its manifesto target of spending 2.5% of GDP on defence but it plans to reach that figure earlier, by 2027, and plans to increase it to 3% during the next Parliament.

Current defence allocation is 2.3% of GDP and to make up the 0.2% shortfall, the government will cut its international development commitment from 0.5% to 0.3%, which the PM says does not detract from the UK’s commitments to Sudan, Ukraine, vaccinations and climate change.

While this decision has been widely welcomed given America’s policy to no longer underpin European security, responses have broadly been in two camps—firstly, that it does not go far enough and secondly shaving 0.2% off the international development budget is not the answer.

2.5% buys you a hearing in the White House but does not go far enough

Many are of the view that the minimum spent on defence should be 3% and sooner rather than later. Speaking on Radio 4’s PM, Lib Dem MP Mike Martin argued against 3% as part of stage 2,  given that in Germany, Chancellor Merz is discussing what collective defence looks like without America, Denmark is considering 3%, Poland 4.5% and the Baltics 5%.

Others believe that the government is taking the safest political route. By reducing the international development budget, which fell from 0.7% to 0.5% in 2020 and is ‘peanuts’ in comparison to other UK spending on healthcare, education and welfare, it avoids making tough choices that would require a real discussion within the Labour Party, the Conservative Party and the electorate.

Reducing Britain’s influence in the global south

The cut to the overseas aid has not been welcomed in the international development sector and has resulted in Anneliese Dodd, the International Development Minister, resigning from her post. While others view these developments as an opening for China to fill in the gap, leaves the UK’s development policy “in tatters” and most importantly fails to understand that defence and international development are both sides of the same coin as the latter tackles conflict, reduces migration, fights disease all of which are important to UK security.